About to Have a Parent Tantrum? Polyvagal-informed practices to help.

Another scenario common to all parents is the feeling of an impending or the presence of an actual parent tantrum.

We have all been there. We become so frustrated, so aggravated with whatever the current situation may be that we become angry, we may raise our voice, we may say or think things we would otherwise never contemplate. In essence, this is the parent equivalent of the classic toddler temper tantrum. How do we manage such a situation?

First, it is important to always remember that we are all human. Our physiology all works the same way. No matter how good our intentions, or how much we practice skills and strategies to manage our physiology, we are still human. As humans, we will not always get things right, we will not always show up or respond the way we would like and we may have reactions, even tantrums, that do not reflect our true nature or desires. This recognition is a component of the non-judgmental acknowledgement of our physiological state.

The first step in managing a parent tantrum, like with all situations, is the acknowledgement of the current physiological state without judgment or criticism. It is important to recall that our response to internal and external cues occurs, via neuroception, beneath conscious awareness and is not deliberately decided. As such, we did not choose to react to a given internal or external cue in a fashion that led to the tantrum. This does not reflect our intentions, values, or how we would like to respond to the stimulus. This is an unconscious reaction mediated by our nervous system.

While the manner in which we neurocept a given stimulus is not under our control, what happens next can be better controlled. If we are able, through training our nervous system, to rapidly identify the shift in our physiology, we are then able to implement the appropriate skills to shift our physiology towards the desired state. Using this concept, we can illustrate the process for the parent tantrum. In response to a particular internal or external stimulus, we have neurocepted a cue of uncertainly, risk, or threat. The resulting physiological response is a shift towards a sympathetic state. The nature and characteristics of a tantrum correspond very closely to this physiological state.

Following identification of the present sympathetic state, we can then implement our skills and strategies to shift our state towards a ventral vagal state through breathing, thinking, relaxing muscle tone, opening posture, and use of our voice. It is important to note that developing a wide array of skills and strategies is ideal as the preferred skill or strategy may vary at different times or under changing circumstances.

In order to provide the greatest opportunity for success in managing our physiology, it is therefore preferable to have many different tools in our proverbial toolbox. As with the case of shifting away from a dorsal vagal state, each successive instance in which we are able to modify our physiology in response to stimuli strengthens our ability to not only do so in the future but also to tolerate increased levels of stress without associated unwanted shifts in our physiology.

As can be appreciated from the above description, there is substantial empowerment available through embodiment of the skills and strategies based upon Polyvagal Theory.

By understanding our physiology and training the ability to manage our physiological state, we are better positioned to be at our best for ourselves and those around us. This approach respects and works with our physiology and does not attempt to overcome or override it. In so doing, we are best able to express our fullest potential in alignment with what we find most important and value most.

REFERENCES

Dana, D. Polyvagal Exercises for Safety and Connection: 50 Client-centered Practices. New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2020.

Dana, D. Anchored: How to Befriend Your Nervous System Using Polyvagal Theory. Boulder, Colorado: Sounds True, 2021.

Delahooke, M. Brain-Body Parenting: How to Stop Managing Behavior and Start Raising Joyful, Resilient Kids. New York: HarperCollins, 2022.

Porges, SW. Polyvagal Safety: Attachment, Communication, Self-Regulation. New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2021.

Porges, SW. The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, Self-Regulation. New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2011.

Porges, SW. Presidential Address, 1994. Orienting in a Defensive World: Mammalian Modifications of our Evolutionary Heritage. A Polyvagal Thoery. Psychophysiol 1995; 32: 301-318.

A special thank you to Dr. Darin Davidson MD for his collaborative interview on Polyvagal Informed Practices.

Nervous System Regulation & Parent Health: Part 1 of 2

Developing the ability to regulate our nervous system is crucial to promote our health, wellbeing, and be at our best in any role in life, particularly parenting. 

Recovery and restoration are essential processes in the promotion of health and wellbeing.  Ventral vagal activation is necessary in order for this to occur.  In addition, a relative lack of ventral vagal tone and increased and chronic sympathetic and dorsal vagal activation have been associated with several physical and mental health conditions, including cardiovascular ailments, impaired immune function, chronic inflammation, anxiety, and depression.

In order to best maintain and enhance our health, an intentional recovery routine is important. 

This includes mindset training, sufficient quantity and duration of sleep, adequate nutrition and hydration, and physical activity.  While it can be challenging, if not impossible, to fully prioritize each of these elements, particularly with young children, it is important to optimize each to the extent possible.  These elements each function to promote ventral vagal activation leading, at least in part, to recovery and restoration.  When multiple of these factors can be combined, the effect is greater than the sum of its parts.  Another important consideration is specific training of mind-based and body-based skills to promote vagal efficiency, thereby further improving ventral vagal activation.

This process is proactive in nature and is at its greatest positive impact when integrated within a daily routine. 

In doing so we not only benefit from the regular effects of ventral vagal activation but also increase our ability to access these strategies and their effects when most in need, specifically during high stakes situations.  In order to best be able to be of service to others, our own health and wellbeing must be optimized.  This is a necessary factor in being the best version of ourselves in any, and all, situations.

Follow this blog for Part 2 on Nervous System Regulation & Parent Health! Visit @parentsuitcase on Instagram and Pinterest! Thank you to our collaborator, Dr. Darin Davidson MD MD, MHSC, FRCSC on this topic. Dr Davidson is a Polyvagal-Informed Coach and Concierge Care Physician who works with professionals both virtually and in-person.

REFERENCES

Dana, D.  Polyvagal Exercises for Safety and Connection: 50 Client-centered Practices.  New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2020.

Dana, D.  Anchored: How to Befriend Your Nervous System Using Polyvagal Theory.  Boulder, Colorado: Sounds True, 2021.

Delahooke, M.  Brain-Body Parenting: How to Stop Managing Behavior and Start Raising Joyful, Resilient Kids.  New York: HarperCollins, 2022.

Porges, SW.  Polyvagal Safety: Attachment, Communication, Self-Regulation.  New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2021.

Porges, SW.  The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, Self-Regulation.  New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2011.

Porges, SW.  Presidential Address, 1994.  Orienting in a Defensive World: Mammalian Modifications of our Evolutionary Heritage.  A Polyvagal Thoery.  Psychophysiol 1995; 32: 301-318.

Polyvagal Informed Parenting

Applying the principles of Polyvagal Theory to parenting is substantially beneficial and empowering. 

The basis for this is that since Polyvagal Theory explains how our physiology responds in response to internal and external cues and stimuli, by embodying this understanding and the related principles in any domain of life, including parenting, we are able to work with our physiology.  As described above, whether or not we choose to acknowledge and understand these processes, they are continuously occurring.  By not embodying these principles we are, effectively, taking the chance that we may react or respond in a skillful and effective fashion.  In contrast, by fully embracing and implementing the polyvagal informed skills and strategies, we provide ourselves the greatest likelihood for performing in our role as humans and parents in the best possible fashion.  In addition these principles apply equally to those around us, including our children.  Recognizing and working with their physiology provides the best opportunity to develop connection with our children and optimize our ability to co-regulate them.

In addition to applying the polyvagal informed practices to ourselves, there are additional considerations in applying these skills and strategies to our parenting. It is important to recognize that just as the resilience of our nervous system is not determined by a lack of dysregulation, the relationships we have, including with our children, is not defined by a lack of conflict or rupture.  Rather, our relationships are better evaluated on the ability to rapidly and effectively repair any ruptures or conflicts which arise.  As we are all human, we will not always respond, react, and behave in the fashion we hope to.  There will be instances, including in our parenting, where we will behave suboptimally.  The recognition that, firstly, we are human and this is not abnormal or unexpected in combination with the acknowledgement that when this occurs, it the ensuing process of repair that is most important and the determinant of the resilience and quality of our relationship can provide substantial freedom and empowerment.

Application of Polyvagal Theory to parenting begins by accepting our physiological state, wherever it may be, as well as that of our child in the present moment.  It is important that this acknowledgement be without judgement or blame.  It is also helpful to recognize that our physiological states, as well as that of our child, can shift and change continuously in response to cues in the internal and external environment.  This makes our, and our child’s, physiological states dynamic in nature.  In addition, we can use the features of our own actions, behaviors, and physiology and that of our child as useful information to determine the current physiological state.  This is also done without criticism or judgement.  For instance, aggressive or attacking behavior should be seen as a reflection of physiological state, indicating that the individual feels under threat, rather than a conscious and deliberate decision.  Specifically, a child who has a tantrum in the grocery store is reflecting a sympathetic physiological state rather than an intent to cause commotion in the public place.  It is important to note that this understanding does not excuse poor behavior, rather it provides a useful explanation for it.

A polyvagal informed perspective to parenting will recognize that children, particularly when young, are not able to effectively and consistently self-regulate. 

Rather they rely upon their caregivers for co-regulation.  Through the process of providing cues of safety, thereby allowing for co-regulation, the child develops over time the ability to self-regulate.  In order to effectively co-regulate, it is important for the caregiver to shift their physiological state towards a ventral vagal predominant state.  This will result in the characteristic features of this physiology, thereby providing cues of safety to the child.  We are not able to project cues of safety and connection if we do not actually feel safe and connected.  It is not possible to fake this feeling.  The question then becomes, particularly in the midst of a challenging situation, for example the public tantrum, how do we shift our physiology to feel safe to be able to co-regulate.

The ability to find cues of safety in the midst of high demand and stressful situations results from two important skills.  The first is the ability to recognize without judgement our own physiological state.  The second is to employ skills and strategies that will shift our physiology in the desired direction.  For instance, during the public tantrum we may recognize that we are shifting into a sympathetic state.  Upon this identification, we can then turn to skills such as breathing, relaxation of facial muscles and posture, use of voice, relaxing our jaw, and finding cues of safety in our internal and external environment to help shift our physiology towards a ventral vagal state.  As we accomplish this, we will be able to co-regulate our child.  These skills are complex and require intentional and deliberate practice in order to develop a level of proficiency.

From the polyvagal informed perspective, it is important to remove cues of uncertainty, risk, and threat to the greatest extent possible from our child’s environment.  Of course, it is not possible to completely remove these potential cues.  For this reason it becomes important to recognize that when a child neurocepts such cues, there will be a predictable physiological shift which will then result in behaviors that can be anticipated.  Maintaining the greatest degree of consistency in parenting is important so that the child is able to predict responses and reactions.  Uncertainty can be a significant cue leading to mobilization towards sympathetic states.  In addition, consequences for behaviors should be carefully considered and chosen so as to avoid introduction of additional cues of uncertainty, risk, and threat.

Continue to follow @Parentsuitcase on Instagram and Pinterest and a special thank you to our collaborative expert content contributor Dr. Davidson MD, MHSC, FRSCS

#polyvagaltheory #positiveparenting #peacefulparenting #polyvagal #polyvagalparenting